Dover Saddlery Is Closing — Here's Where to Buy Your Tack and Horse Supplies in 2026
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — and in some cases you'll save money too!
If you've heard the news — Dover Saddlery, one of the most beloved equestrian retailers in North America, is closing its doors. For generations of hunter jumper riders, Dover was the go-to for everything from show coats to saddle pads to leather care. Walking into a Dover store felt like coming home.
It's a loss for our community — and if you're wondering where to go now, you're not alone. Here's a complete guide to the best Dover Saddlery alternatives for hunter jumper riders and trainers in 2026.
What's Happening With Dover Saddlery?
Dover Saddlery has been taken over by Gordon Brothers, a restructuring firm, and is in the process of closing locations and liquidating stores nationwide. While no formal bankruptcy filing has been made, going-out-of-business sales are underway at locations across the country.
For many riders this is the end of an era. But the good news is that the equestrian retail market has never had more quality options — and several of them are actually better suited to the modern hunter jumper rider than Dover ever was.
Best Dover Saddlery Alternatives in 2026
1. SmartPak — Best for Supplements and Horse Care
Link: https://share.smartpakequine.com/eliteequinemarketplace!50d8de2303!a?locale=en
For supplements, horse care products, blankets, and stable supplies, SmartPak is the most natural Dover replacement — and right now it's the best deal in equestrian retail.
If you start a new SmartPak AutoShip of $40 or more per month you get 50% off your first shipment. That's an incredible saving on the supplements your horse is already on — or the perfect time to start a joint, digestive, or coat supplement you've been considering.
SmartPak's subscription supplement program is unmatched — customize your horse's daily SmartPak, never run out, and save every single month. Their blanket selection, hoof care products, and horse care range rivals everything Dover carried and then some.
2. Amazon — Best for Tack Room Supplies, Show Day Essentials, and Rider Apparel
Link: https://a.co/d/06gyjFib
Amazon has quietly become one of the best sources for equestrian products — and with Prime shipping, it's often faster than Dover ever was. I've curated my favorite finds specifically for hunter jumper riders across several lists:
🐴 For the Horse — grooming, leg care, show day essentials, barn supplies
👗 Riding Attire — breeches, show coats, helmets, gloves, tall boots
🏆 Horse Show Essentials — everything you need from barn to ring
✨ Equestrian Chic — elevated finds for riders, home decor, barn life, and country style curated to look high-end without the high-end price tag
Affordable luxury finds for equestrians, cozy farmhouse living, and everything in between — all sponsored by Elite Equine Marketplace.
3. Chewy — Best for Feed, Fly Control, and Veterinary Products
Link: https://chewpanions.chewy.com/eliteequineofficial
For heavy items like feed, fly control, wound care, and veterinary products — Chewy is your best Dover replacement. Free shipping on orders over $49 means you're saving on the bulky barn supplies that used to require a Dover store trip.
Chewy carries all the brands you know — Farnam, Absorbine, Vetrolin, Vetericyn, Purina, Nutrena, Triple Crown, and more. Their Subscribe and Save option means your horse's essentials arrive automatically every month without you having to think about it.
4. Elite Equine Marketplace — Best for Used Tack and Consignment
Link: https://eliteequinemarketplace.com/tack-equipment-apparel
For used and consignment English saddles, tack, horse boots, blankets, and equipment — Elite Equine Marketplace is the best Dover alternative specifically for the hunter jumper community.
Unlike general resale platforms like eBay or Facebook groups, every buyer and seller on Elite Equine Marketplace is a hunter jumper rider or trainer — meaning your CWD saddle listing reaches exactly the buyers who know what it is and what it's worth. No explaining what a martingale is. No trail riders enquiring about your jumping saddle.
Whether you're looking to sell tack from a cleared-out Dover haul or find quality used equipment at fair prices — Elite Equine Marketplace is built for you.
5. Riding Warehouse — Best Overall Tack and Apparel Retailer
Link: https://www.ridingwarehouse.com
Riding Warehouse has become one of the most beloved equestrian retailers among hunter jumper riders — and for good reason. Their selection of English tack, riding apparel, boots, and horse care products rivals Dover's at competitive prices, with fast shipping and genuinely helpful customer service.
They carry all the brands your Dover order probably included — Ariat, Pikeur, Samshield, Equifit, Veredus, and more. If you're replacing your Dover habit with one single full-service retailer, Riding Warehouse is it.
6. State Line Tack — Best for Budget-Friendly Basics
Link: https://www.statelinetack.com
For everyday barn supplies, grooming products, and budget-friendly essentials — State Line Tack is a solid Dover replacement at accessible price points. Fly spray, grooming supplies, everyday saddle pads, and stable basics at prices that won't break the bank.
7. Schneiders Saddlery — Best for Blankets and Stable Supplies
Link: https://www.schneiderssaddlery.com
If Dover was your blanket source, Schneiders should be your first stop. Their selection of turnout blankets, fly sheets, and stable supplies is extensive and fairly priced — one of the best in the business for quality blankets at every price point.
8. Shop Directly From Your Favorite Brands
For premium brands you were buying through Dover — consider going direct:
Ariat — https://www.ariat.com
Samshield — https://www.samshield.com
Equifit — https://www.equifit.com
Pikeur — through authorized US retailers
Going direct often means better selection, more accurate sizing information, and direct access to customer service for high-ticket items.
What About Dover's Used Tack and Consignment?
Dover carried a significant amount of consignment and used tack — particularly saddles. If you're looking to buy or sell used English saddles, tack, and equipment now that Dover is gone, Elite Equine Marketplace is the most targeted replacement for the hunter jumper community.
List your used Dover haul — saddles, boots, blankets, bridles — and reach hunter jumper buyers who know exactly what you're selling.
List your tack today: https://eliteequinemarketplace.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Dover Saddlery permanently closing?
Yes — Dover Saddlery is in the process of closing all locations nationwide following a takeover by Gordon Brothers. Going-out-of-business sales are underway. Check your local store for closing sale details.
Where can I buy horse supplements now that Dover is closing?
SmartPak is the best replacement for supplements — and right now new customers get 50% off their first AutoShip order of $40 or more. Shop here: https://share.smartpakequine.com/eliteequinemarketplace!50d8de2303!a?locale=en
Where can I buy Ariat boots now that Dover is closing?
Riding Warehouse carries a full selection of Ariat footwear and apparel at https://www.ridingwarehouse.com. You can also find Ariat products in my Amazon storefront at https://a.co/d/06gyjFib.
Where can I sell my Dover tack haul?
Elite Equine Marketplace is the best platform for selling used hunter jumper tack to a targeted audience of buyers who understand the brands and value. List at https://eliteequinemarketplace.com.
What is the best online tack store for hunter jumper riders?
Riding Warehouse is the best overall online tack retailer. For supplements SmartPak is unmatched — especially with 50% off your first shipment right now. For used and consignment tack, Elite Equine Marketplace connects hunter jumper sellers with qualified buyers exclusively.
Will Dover Saddlery reopen online?
There is currently no confirmed information about Dover Saddlery reopening in any form. Their website may remain active through the liquidation process but long-term operations are uncertain.
🐴 The Bottom Line
Dover Saddlery leaving is genuinely the end of an era. But the hunter jumper world has always been resilient — and the alternatives available today are more modern, more targeted, and more convenient than Dover ever was.
Whether you're stocking up during the closing sales, looking for a new go-to retailer, or trying to sell the tack you cleared out — the resources above have you covered.
And don't forget — if you're starting fresh on supplements, right now is the perfect time. New SmartPak customers get 50% off their first AutoShip shipment — the best deal in horse care right now.
👉 Start your SmartPak — 50% off first shipment: https://share.smartpakequine.com/eliteequinemarketplace!50d8de2303!a?locale=en
👉 Shop my Amazon equestrian favorites: https://a.co/d/06gyjFib
👉 Shop horse supplies on Chewy: https://chewpanions.chewy.com/eliteequineofficial
👉 Browse and list tack on EEM: https://eliteequinemarketplace.com/tack-equipment-apparel
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This post contains affiliate links for SmartPak, Chewy, and Amazon. I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
